1898 Revenues: Graded Stamps: Perpetuating the Decline of Stamp Collecting -- Top 20 Google Hits

Sunday, December 13, 2009

Graded Stamps: Perpetuating the Decline of Stamp Collecting -- Top 20 Google Hits

I conducted a simple exercise on December 13 at 19:00 GMT and Googled the term "graded stamps". The search returned the following summarized results:

13 graded stamps dealers
2 stamp grading firms (both PSE)
2 eBay pages
2 collector sites
1 dealer association (ASDA)

The list of detailed hits is below.   Most of the hits were what I expected to see: dealers in the trade and the pages of Professional Stamp Experts. It is clear there are many trying to make a living off of graded stamps. The ASDA page is merely a listing page for dealers that trade in graded stamps.

But I found a page I had not seen before. Of the two collector sites that came up, one was this blog you are reading right now. The other was the site of the Virtual Stamp Club. And back in July 2007, Ken Lawrence posted a particularly devastating criticism of stamp grading on this site, leading with a statement that grading is bad for the hobby. It helps to know that such an established and respected professional has this opinion, though it is clear that it hasn't stopped grading in the intervening two and a half years. I've often wondered whether there were others out there with similar issues. As a busy professional living outside the United States, I don't and have never had any real opportunity to attend stamp shows or stamp meetings to talk about my hobby.  The internet is my lifeline to the stamp world and it is great to find some writing that confirms my own opinions. If you have not read his piece, you should.

Top 20 Google hits for "graded stamps"
1.    GradedStamps.com (A)
2.    EandMgradedstamps.com (A)
3.    JerryConnollyStamps.com (A)
4.    store.Malack.com (A)
5.    PSEstamp.com (B)
6.    SuperbPhilatelics.com (A)
7.    pages.eBay.com (C)
8.    SHPgraded.com (A)
9.    CGstamps.com (A)
10. reviews.ebay.com (C)
11. PSEstamp.com (B)
12. Century-Stamps.com (A)
13. mcphilatelics.com   (A)
14. crotonstamp.com (A)
15. 1898revenues.blogspot.com   (D)
16. volovskirarities.com (A)
17. BruceMacDonaldStamps.com (A)
18. ASDAonline.com (E)
19. mestampshoppe.com (A)
20. virtualstampclub.com/grading_kl.html (D)

Key:
A - graded stamp dealer
B - stamp grading company
C - eBay
D - collector site
E - delaer assocation

No comments:

Unusual Ink on the 1898 Series Dollar Values

From fugitive ink to color changelings with unknown origins. These are both copies of R191. Can only exposure to light produce the color changes you see in stamp on the right? Or possibly a soak in bleach or other chemical? I doubt it. These stamps have so many examples of changelings that there must be something else happening. The ink used on this dark green series of stamps was different than that known on any other BEP printed stamps, never mind the varnish square. It is likely the BEP was experimenting with ink on this issue. Inks are discussed further if you click on the stamps.

Collecting Cancels

Welcome to 1898 Revenues, a website that features the stamps used to pay the Spanish-American war taxes imposed by the US Government starting in July, 1898. But while this site features those stamps in general, a focus is on their cancels, and on the firms that applied them. Unlike US postage stamps, which were canceled by the US Post Office and now Postal Service, revenue stamps were ordered to be canceled by their users in such a way that the identity of the user and the date was included in the cancel. This makes the collecting possibilities nearly endless, so that a single variety of stamp, for example, the 2 cent battleship stamp intended to pay documentary taxes, had potentially millions of different users, and therefore as many different cancels. Please browse the site and discover the collecting possibilities, made so much more accessible now through online sales. Cancels on these stamps have become much more interesting and accessible with the massive amounts of archival and historical data available on line. Rather than hours spent in libraries or with heavy volumes to identify cancels, search engines allow for cancel sleuthing at home.

Battleship Proprietary Printed Cancels: Updating the Joyce/Chappell Lists

In the 1950s, Morton Dean Joyce updated a list of printed cancels on the battleship proprietaries compiled by Clarence Chappell. Joyce's is a very long list consisting of more than one hundred companies and thousands of cancel dates. In the years since Joyce completed his list, many new cancel dates have been demonstrated to exist, and an update of the 1950s list is needed.

This site is attempting that update. Using the Joyce/Chappell lists and the former collection of Henry Tolman (ARA #25) as a base, a gradual effort will be made to post updated lists to the best of my knowledge, making a call for those that can contribute new dates and new images of those cancels.

Following in this column are quick links to excel files of these lists by company. Also are links to the posts that I have made on this blog regarding these companies and their cancels.

Criteria for Cancels Included in these Updated Lists

The updated lists on this site will not include handstamped cancels. Printed and typed cancels will be included. This differs from the Chappell and Joyce criteria for inclusion.

Joyce used criteria for including cancels in his lists based on Chappell's original criteria. From the introduction of Chappell's original list: "Only the printed and typed cancels will be given consideration in this list. The only exception being those firms who also had private die stamps in this period. The handstamps of these few companies are of general interest and I feel they should be included." I don't think the "general interest" consideration is a strong enough reason to complicate an already complicated set of lists. The handstamps listed by Chappell and Joyce are not printed by definition, they are likely not exhaustive, and by virtue of being handstamps are prone to innumerable types and subtypes. I reason that if a new list is of printed cancels, we should keep it that way, and let others that have have done more work on the subject of proprietary handstamps handle those cancels.

Thus, if you are interested in the handstamp cancels of any of the firms in the updated printed cancel lists, please refer to the excellent work of Robert Mustacich and his Battleship Desk Reference at http://www.battleship-revenues.com/.

The practice of eliminating handstamp cancels from the updated lists will have implications for the revision of cancel types from the Joyce lists. For example, the first few Antikamnia cancel types according to both Joyce and Chappell are handcancels. These cancels will no longer be included as cancel types.

The goal will be to minimize confusion for those who come to collect these cancels and make sense out of them.

Sunday, December 13, 2009

Graded Stamps: Perpetuating the Decline of Stamp Collecting -- Top 20 Google Hits

No comments:

Post a Comment

1898 Revenues' Post Archive

Blog Index: Access to all 1898 Revenues posts since March 2009

1898 Revenue Stamp Links:

John Langlois' Memberships

Collecting Interests

1898 Revenues Wanted

Values for Series of 1898 Revenue Stamps - The "Battleship Revenues"

Popular Posts

Frank Sente's One Cent Battleship Documentary Exhibit

American Express Printed Cancels

Len McMaster's One Cent Franklin Exhibit

2 Cent Documentary Battleship Calendar

On-Document Uses Featuring Frank Sente

St. Louis Provisionals Featuring Hermann Ivester

Documentary Printed Cancels: The Fullerton List

Bob Hohertz on 1898 Stamped Paper

Frank Sente's American Philatelist 1898 Revenues Cover Story

Battleship Proprietary Printed Cancels: Updating the Joyce/Chappell Lists

Quick Links to Updated Proprietary Printed Cancels Lists

Snyder, Chaffee & Co., Not Strong Cobb & Co.

Hobron Printed Cancels

Anglo-American Drug Printed Cancels

The Centaur Company Printed Cancels

M.M. Fenner Printed Cancels

HAMLIN'S WIZARD OIL PRINTED CANCELS

FEATURE: SEARLE AND HERETH PRINTED CANCELS

Feature: G. H. Mumm Printed Cancels

FEATURE: CHATTANOOGA MEDICINE COMPANY PRINTED CANCELS

Criteria for Cancels Included in these Updated Lists

Join the American Revenue Association